Encourage, Support, and Bite Your Tongue

Grandparents, that is. How ironic -- just as I decided to write a post about the plight of today's Grandma and Grandpa, researchers from Johns Hopkins published a study in the journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics that shows children are less likely to be injured when they are in the care of grandparents than with their stay-at-home moms. Turns out that while the aging Baby Boomers are feeling a generational gap -- maybe even a rift in some cases -- in child-raising attitudes between their own children and themselves, their skills have withstood the advancing years.

Before I go any further, there is a caveat. I am not a grandmother yet, but I have endless stories to retell from those I know who are. The tales are all different, but the ending is always the same: "...and I just bite my tongue."

At least we know now that there is a significant advantage for the 30 percent of children under age 5 (U.S. Census Bureau) who are receiving child care from a grandparent! But it doesn't change the reality that, with all their competence and watchful eyes, there is a totally dissimilar approach to parenting between the Boomers and their own offspring, the Gen Xers.

This is not a judgment, but rather an observation. When my children were going to school, we packed their lunch, kissed them goodbye, and most often didn't know until 3:30 if they had a bellyache and had gone to the nurse. No, we weren't shirking our responsibilities as parents; we just usually weren't home when the school nurse called - and there were no such things as cell phones!

Contrast that scenario with today's: not only do parents have mobile phones, but so do many kids! While the technology tether has been dubbed the longest umbilical cord in the world, the fact is that everyone has gotten used to the expectation of parents being highly involved in their kids' lives; some will say overinvolved, which has led to the term, "overparenting."

But I digress. How do we reconcile these differences in approach when both age groups are focused on "parenting" or "grandparenting" the same child? Okay, so now we know that the young mother who insisted that her parents attend a certification class for grandparenting (even though the grandmother was an EMT) might not have had to worry so much. What we can't resolve, however, is that grandparents, in the role of guiding forces, sometimes see things through a diametrically opposed lens.

One of the most poignant - and jarring - narratives I have heard recently is the friend (who is an educator) who told me, "I cringe when my daughter tells me why she called the school." I am not taking sides here (okay, I am trying not to).

What I propose is a cease-fire; an understanding by both generations of the disparate motivations that underlie two vastly different methods.

Followed immediately by the mantra: "Encourage, support, bite your tongue." We had our turn, and it was in another era - my generation was giddy with confidence and optimism, we were rebellious, and we had several channels on TV! We can encourage and support; we can be [exhausted] cheerleaders; we can foster strong bonds with our grands. My smartest friends all live by this thinking.

(And AARP suggests that we create a Family Childcare Agreement that deals with questions from adult children like, "Will you do it our way? Will our children be safe? Can you learn new tricks?")

[I hope that my daughter-in-law will gently remind me of this post when I have a grandchild!]

In the meantime, we grandparents (or grandparents-to-be) can shore up our legacies - whether it is by being a work-day nanny or a sage and trusted mentor, by providing the "value-added" component of raising children in the 21st century. Among the myriad conversations, trips, and activities, there is always a place on the window-seat to curl up and read aloud. I love Kenneth Grahame's "The Wind in the Willows" -- it is a heartwarming story of friendship.

The message of the yarn is one worth underscoring when evaluating the role of grandparent: "I love these little people."

1 Comment

The role of a grandparent is not to compete with the mother or father in bringing up the child. A contest between the generations results in negativity and conflict. I think that common sense would lead one to acknowledge that the grandmother or grandfather could enhance positive parenting by using tools such as attention and affection. She/He should keep the lines of communication open between the generations and be a good listener. I applaud you on your mention of reading to the grandchildren and I would extend this to include telling them interesting stories about family lore. With parents so busy juggling careers and the home and by often being overwhelmed by the challenge of a time deficit, the grandparents have the opportunity to reinforce the stability of the family relationships.

Leave a comment

About Campfire Stories

“Even in an age of computer games and electronic toys, you can’t beat a good story – especially when it is offered by a caring adult.” So said William Bennett, author of “The Book of Virtues,” prompting me to reflect on all the stories I have seen unfold over my years of working with children and families (About Marla) and to realize that I could use many of these as examples of what works and what doesn’t work when it comes to raising resilient, independent, self-disciplined, and happy children. With the backdrop of current news, societal trends, and the latest research, I seek to prompt the best parenting decisions to help parents nurture productive, connected children who can navigate the world on their own. Not surprisingly, the campfire metaphor is ideal, since the camp experience itself is so conducive to building these youth development assets. So please join the conversation, either by commenting on a post that resonates or riles, or by e-mailing me with comments or ideas at blog@MarlaColeman.com.

Recent Entries

Close